At first, looking at the most current information by the Republican Party (and from incumbant Republican Senator Norm Coleman himself), it looks like Al Franken is a tax dodger, a hypocritical liberal who has gone out of his way to not pay his taxes. Even CBS picked up the story from the Politico and it suggests that this could possibly be a problem. 

There's only one problem: Al did pay all of his income taxes, he just did it in the wrong state. And here's another thing: why, exactly, would Al Franken pay ALL of his income taxes in New York state and Minnesota if he was trying scam the government? Given that there are 17 other states demanding income taxes from him, and at least half of them have lower income taxes, wouldn't it have been more devious of him to pay taxes in those states instead, since it would be less than paying them in NY and MN?

Right. It's potentially damaging, and it's a shame because he's just now beginning to pull ahead of Norm Coleman. This is the type of thing the Republican Party can distort in any way imaginable without any trouble whatsoever. And it already is. "Paying taxes is an obligation that I think Minnesotans expect to be adhered to, and that Minnesotans do," says Norm Coleman. Sounds like a good thing, but Al Franken paying his taxes isn't the issue. He just paid them to the wrong state, and he probably ended up paying MORE than he should have, given Minnesota's and New York's high state income taxes.